Lifting the Curtain on the Reviewer's Art

Lisa Hirsch

November 8, 2005

Originally published in San Francisco Classical Voice


Classical music audience members can do quite a bit to enhance their concert-going experience through advance preparation; Robert Commanday and Michelle Dulak Thomson talked about this on January 4, 2004, in an SFCV editorial called “Be Prepared.” Among other things, Commanday and Thomson suggested reviewing the texts for song recitals, choral concerts, and operas, previewing program notes, listening to a recording, and, for those who read music, reviewing the score. 


But what if you’re a reviewer? What level of preparation is expected, required, desirable for a reviewer?


In a typical Bay Area season, you can hear music written from about 1000 A. D. to yesterday, performed by groups ranging in size from a soloist to the hundreds required for Mahler’s Eighth Symphony. SFCV’s writers are a varied group, as you can tell if you read the two-line  biographies that appear at the end of each review. Some of us are professional musicians or composers; some of us are in academia; some of us are dedicated amateur musicians; some of us are experienced listeners who might or might not have a background as performers or academics.


It’s a given that a reviewer will be familiar with a fairly wide range of music and musical styles, but it’s impossible for a single individual to know it all, whether from scores, personal experience as a performer, or recordings. The standard repertory of the last 300 years includes thousands of orchestral, solo, operatic, and chamber works by dozens of the most important composers; in the LP and CD eras, an enormous amount of hitherto hard-to-find music by worthy but not-quite-first tier composers has been recorded. (Havergal Brian cq, Franz Berwald cq, and Jón Leifs cq, anyone?) Reach back before 1700 and you’re faced with more huge repertories of secular and sacred music.


So what’s a reviewer to do? As in so many things, the answer is: it depends.


If a work to be reviewed is part of that core repertory, there’s a pretty good chance the reviewer is already familiar with it. It’s tough for a music lover to miss the Beethoven or Brahms or Mozart or Haydn symphonies, the Beethoven string quartets, “Rhapsody in Blue” or the Rachmaninov piano concertos, Le Nozze di Figaro or Aida. (Yes, let’s assume our theoretical reviewer is a music lover. If she’s not, perhaps she would be happier in another line of work.) So our reviewer isn’t starting from scratch. If a work is warhorse, no preparation at all might be necessary. And that’s just what Joshua Kosman of the San Francisco Chronicle told me: “For the Tchaikovsky Fourth Symphony,” and, he implied, similarly familiar pieces, “I do nothing.”

For some pieces, a reviewer might decide to look at the score or read through it at the piano. Scores of standard repertory works are easy enough to find; they might be in the reviewer’s personal collection, and if not, they’re readily available at a big public library or academic music library. Or the reviewer might listen to a favorite recording or two or three, perhaps as a refresher if he hadn’t heard the work recently. Even reviewers’ personal recording collections vary considerably in size; Alex Ross of The New Yorker once mentioned his 10,000-odd CDs in a blog posting, while New York Times critic Bernard Holland dropped my jaw some years ago when he said he owned only about 300 records.


Reviewers vary considerably in what they think is appropriate, of course. One reviewer might prefer to avoid recordings in order to clear all preconceived ideas from her head, but Michelle Dulak Thomason said in the editorial mentioned above that if she knows a work well, she listens to several recordings to remind her of the range of possibilities inherent in the piece. 


New or unusual music presents different challenges. The composer might be completely new to the reviewer and the work might not yet have been published. Andrew Porter, critic of The New Yorker for some twenty years, typically tried to obtain a perusal score from the composer or his publisher before an important premiere; Porter attended rehearsals when he could and sometimes talked to the composer or the performers about the work. 


Joshua Kosman does much the same thing. For a big premiere, especially of a large-scale work such as Doctor Atomic, he’ll go to some lengths to see the score. He also attends the open rehearsal series of the San Francisco Symphony, and not just when new or unfamiliar works are being performed, because the format makes it easier and more appropriate to bring a score along for reference. 


If the score isn’t available and the work hasn’t been recorded, a reviewer may immerse himself in a composer’s style by reviewing the composer’s other scores or listen to recordings of other works. I expect the premiere of Doctor Atomic sold quite a few CDs for John Adams and Nonesuch, for example. 


Very old music presents some of the same challenges as very new music. More reviewers have heard (or performed in) the Beethoven symphonies than have heard or sung the masses of Obrecht or the secular music of Binchois. Early music groups often prepare their own performing editions, especially if the group is connected with a university or directed by a scholar; the performers may even be playing from photocopies of the original manuscripts. Faced with the need to evaluate an edition or performance style chosen by an early music ensemble, a reviewer may dip into the scholarly literature on a composer or period or work. Of course, this is also true of more recent music; if you’re reviewing a Rossini or early Verdi opera, it would be helpful to know what vocal ornamentation was common and expected when the work was composed.


Different kinds of concerts also call for different kinds of preparation. If a solo recital is under review, the reviewer might listen to some of the performer’s recordings to get a sense of his or her style and strengths. The same goes for a famous conductor leading the San Francisco Symphony for the first time. Choral concerts and vocal recitals can have as many as twenty to twenty-five short works by sundry composers of various eras programmed; in such a situation, it’s difficult to do a lot of advance preparation, and the reviewer may have rely on her general knowledge and her on-the-spot observations.


A number of recent American operas have had literary sources that a reviewer might peruse for background. An adaptation may be more or less successful, and what the librettist and composer left in or out is a legitimate matter of interest. Andre Previn’s A Streetcar Named Desire is based on an iconic American play that also gave birth to a famous film; Carlisle cq Floyd’s Cold Sassy Tree and Mark Adamo’s Little Women are both based on novels. The libretto for Doctor Atomic was drawn from many sources, and quite a few reviewers, including Ross and Kosman, consulted Richard Rhodes’s The Making of the Atomic Bomb for historical background.


There are circumstances in which a reviewer may seem to be out of luck: a work is new and the score isn’t readily available, or the work is very old, or rarely heard, or has never been published. But a look at the New Grove Dictionary of Music and Musicians might provide pointers to articles or books about the work or composer or period; consulting a music librarian can also be enormously helpful. Performing organization and composers will often be eager to assist, as well. 


The lead time from receiving an assignment to the performance to the date of publication also bears on how much preparation a reviewer does. “I have a lot more time to prepare beforehand here at the New Yorker, given that my columns come every few weeks as opposed to every other day. But I did much of the same preparation when I was at the Times, as time allowed,” says Alex Ross. He prepares by reading background articles, studying scores, and listening to recordings related to particular pieces or composers.


There’s something to be said for reviewing a work cold, even when the reviewer has the opportunity for preparation. For example, Kosman read Cold Sassy Tree prior to seeing the operatic version for the first time, and says that his experience of the opera was therefore different from that of attendees who didn’t know the novel; that might have been a drawback rather than advantage. 


In the 21st century, we have a wealth of scholarly and recorded resources to back us up; we have access on line or in libraries to decades of reviews and writing about classical music. Those are luxuries earlier critics didn’t have. It’s worth considering what the Beethoven symphonies would have sounded like to a listener who hadn’t heard much Haydn, Mozart, or C.P.E. Bach, or how a critic would have approached a radical work such as Tristan und Isolde in the 1860s. I became acquainted with Tristan at a time when I already knew the music of the Second Viennese School, an experience no 19th century reviewer could have had.


Limited preparation also makes it possible to experience the shock of the new even with old music. I was lucky enough to review a Music@Menlo concert this past summer that included the Schubert String Quintet in C Major. I’d never heard the work before; I have broader and deeper knowledge of the operatic and early music repertory than of 19th century chamber music. I knew the two Beethoven pieces on the program, and because I know plenty of Schubert, I did no preparation for the Quintet. The result was a transcendent concert-going experience, the kind every listener hopes for, but rarely gets. The second theme of the first movement left me in tears; I was utterly transported for the rest of the piece, and I was still enraptured an hour after the concert ended. 


I’m glad to have had that serendipitous experience. I’m not suggesting that reviewers should avoid preparing for concerts, and I certainly don’t plan to give it up myself. What reviewers are being paid for, really, is our ability to evaluate both a work and a performance on the fly, and then write intelligently about what we heard for an audience that includes readers of all levels of musical experience. We can prepare very specifically for a particular concert; our cumulative experience and knowledge of music are the general preparation that we bring to everything we review, and it’s that knowledge that allows us to sometimes review cold, without advance preparation.


No comments: