Opera San José's six-performance run of Puccini's evergreen La Bohème opened this past Saturday at the California Theatre in, of course, San José. It's the kind of opera that's so spectacularly well-written and so theatrical that, if well-directed, you'll come out of it weeping, and, well, I certainly teared up regularly during the performance.
Opera San José owns this production and has staged it before. It moves the action from the 1850s into the 1920s, but I can't say that this was very obvious, except in the French soldiers' uniforms in the second act. There are no telephones, biplanes, or automobiles to tip you off, no walking wounded from the recently-concluded Great War. The women's fashions aren't flapper-era, either. I don't see any gains from this temporal relocation, but neither did it do any harm.
More importantly, Michelle Cuizon's direction was suitably lively; funny or serious when required and always snappy. I particularly liked the end of act 3, where you get comedy and tragedy on stage at the same time, with Marcello and Musetta having it out on the left for probably the 20th time, while on the right Mimì and Rodolfo are weeping quietly together. Kim A. Tolman's realistic sets of a Parisian garret, Café Momus, and the Barrière d'Enfer look good and work well.
This run has two sopranos as Mimì, Kearstin Piper Brown, whom I saw on Saturday, and Mikayla Sager, whose work I know from when she was an Adler Fellow. I feel you can't go wrong with either of them! I'd seen and loved Brown last year in Opera Parallèle's The Shining; she has a beautiful voice with great control and lots of spin, making her an ideal Mimì. Sager has a darker, equally beautiful voice and, like Brown, is a wonderful artist. She was fabulous a couple of years ago in Desdemona's long scene at the end of Verdi's Otello. So, as I said, you can't go wrong withe either soprano.
Also really wonderful in this production is Kodon Choi as Marcello, Rodolfo the poet's painter sidekick, the on-and-off lover of Musetta. Choi has a gorgeous dark voice that sounds built for the big Verdi baritone roles. I wouldn't be surprised to see him as Rigoletto or Renato or one of those guys in his future appearances. WooYoung Yoon is an appealing Rodolfo, with a reedy voice and a tendency to go sharp when his voice is under pressure.
And there we get to a solvable problem in the production: the California Theatre is very small, seating around 1120 people, and Joseph Marcheso, Opera San José's music director, is conducting enthusiastically and, at times, rather too loudly. This affects Yoon a lot, when he's trying to make himself heard, and it's particularly a problem for the show's Musetta, Melissa Sondhi. She was a good Barbarina in the fabulous Marriage of Figaro a couple of seasons back, and she's a fine actress, but she has an unusually small voice for Musetta, and she's getting drowned out too often. My plus-one for the evening, a horn player who knows the score well, detected orchestral balance issues, too.
The rest of the cast is perfectly lovely and together they make a great ensemble cast: Jesús Vincente Murillo's Schaunard, Younggwang Park's Colline, and Philip Skinner's Benoit and Alcindoro are all good.
Four performances remain, on November 22 at 7:30 p.m., November 24 and 30 at 2:00 p.m., and December 1 at 2:00 p.m.
See also Joshua Kosman's review.
2 comments:
Did you mean to say "I particularly liked the end of Act 3, where you get comedy and tragedy...." in the 3rd paragraph?
It's also a bit disconcerting to read that Joseph Marcheso doesn't always know when to "curb his enthusiasm" when he conducts, i.e. to keep the orchestra volume under control so as not to strain the singers' voices. (This is also a criticism frequently leveled at Yannick with respect to the Met, as you know.)
On the brighter side, it's nice to read about Jesus Vicente Murillo and good work there, as he sang with OTSL a few seasons back; fine, fine singer.
The comment about the production being moved to the 1920's reminded me of an OperaVision video of a 'La boheme' production by Opera de Monte Carlo, which solved the logical logistics question of Act II by setting the characters at tables inside Cafe Momus with them in the foreground, with all the spectacle of Paris in the background, i.e. the inside looking out (an incredibly obvious solution, which somehow never occurred to me before that video). I wonder if this production did something like that.
Yes, indeed, that is what I meant. I've fixed that typo.
I have heard that about YNS, but I haven't seen him conduct live in several years. I think the week I saw Elektra and Parsifal was the last time. 2018, maybe?
Act 2 had the usual outdoor Café Momus scene, with people wandering around and sometimes going in and out of a storefront on the right.
Post a Comment